This small cemetery was located on Jimmie Creek in S35, T20N, R16W in Cedar Creek Township. Graves 1-6 were on the north side of a road and graves 7-12 were on the south side of the road. The road is unnamed on the map it simply says "To Flippin".
The information on the relocation map states the graves in this cemetery were scheduled to be moved to the New Wildcat Cemetery in Marion Co. A new Wildcat Cemetery apparently wasn't built and the remains from the old Wildcat Cemetery were moved to the Fairview Cemetery in Flippin. However, a search at Find-A-Grave and Arkansas Gravestones website doesn't turn up any of these names in Fairview Cemetery or in any other cemetery on those sites.
If the grave included a tombstone the tombstone was moved with the body.
pdf map Cain Cemetery (opens in a new window or tab)
Column #1 is the grave number in the old cemetery and column #3 is the grave number in the new cemetery.