| Prisoner/Alias | Crime | Date Hanged |
| Allen, Malachi | Murder | Apr 19, 1889 |
| Arcine, James | Murder | Jun 26, 1885 |
| Billy, John | Murder | Apr 3, 1874 |
| Billy, John | Murder | Jan 16, 1890 |
| Bogles, Gus | Murder | Jul 6, 1888 |
| Brown, William | Murder | Sep 9, 1881 |
| Buck, Rufus | Rape | Jul 1, 1896 |
| Burris, Jimmon | Murder | Jan 16, 1890 |
| Busby, Sheppard | Murder | Apr 27, 1892 |
| Campbell, Edmund | Murder | Sep 3, 1875 |
| Childers, John | Murder | Aug 15, 1873 |
| Crow, Jackson | Murder | Apr 27, 1888 |
| Crumpton, Boudinot/Bood Burris | Murder | Jun 30, 1891 |
| Davis, John | Murder | Jul 11, 1884 |
| Davis, Lewis | Rape | Jul 1, 1896 |
| Davis, Lucky | Rape | Jul 1, 1896 |
| Diggs, James | Murder | Dec 20, 1878 |
| Echols, John T. | Murder | Jan 14, 1887 |
| Evans, Daniel | Murder | Sep 3, 1875 |
| Filmore, Isaac | Murder | Apr 3, 1874 |
| Fooy, Samuel | Murder | Sep 3, 1875 |
| French, William | Murder | Jun 29, 1883 |
| Fulsom, Edward | Murder | Jun 30, 1882 |
| Goin, Sam | Murder | Jan 16, 1890 |
| Goldsby, Crawford/Cherokee Bill | Murder | Mar 17, 1896 |
| Hampton, Silas | Murder | Oct 7, 1887 |
| Harris, Austin | Murder | Jan 16, 1890 |
| Hill, Owen | Murder | Apr 27, 1888 |
| Holder, Lewis | Murder | Jul 25, 1894 |
| Isaacs, Webber | Murder | Apr 30, 1896 |
| Ishtanubbee, Gibson | Murder | Apr 21, 1876 |
| Jackson, Joseph | Murder | Apr 23, 1886 |
| James, Calvin | Murder | Jul 23, 1886 |
| Jones, Jefferson | Murder | Jan 16, 1890 |
| July, Maoma | Rape | Jul 1, 1896 |
| Kalijah, Seaborn/Seaborn Green | Murder | Oct 7, 1887 |
| Lamb, James | Murder | Jan 14, 1887 |
| Leach, William | Murder | Apr 21, 1876 |
| Mankiller, Smoker | Murder | Sep 3, 1875 |
| Manley, Abler | Murder | Sep 9, 1881 |
| Manley, Amos | Murder | Sep 9, 1881 |
| Martin, Joseph | Murder | Jun 29, 1883 |
| Massey, Robert | Murder | Apr 13, 1883 |
| McCarty, Patrick | Murder | Apr 8, 1887 |
| McClish, Impson | Murder | Jan 15, 1875 |
| McGee, Orpheus | Murder | Apr 21, 1876 |
| McGowen, Patrick | Murder | Sep 9, 1881 |
| Mills, James | Murder | Apr 19, 1889 |
| Moore, James | Murder | Sep 3, 1875 |
| Moss, George | Murder | Apr 27, 1888 |
| O'Dell, Albert | Murder | Jan 14, 1887 |
| Padgett, George W. | Murder | Sep 9, 1881 |
| Parchmeal, William | Murder | Jun 26, 1885 |
| Peters, Samuel | Murder | Sep 8, 1876 |
| Phillips, William | Murder | Apr 17, 1885 |
| Pierce, George | Murder | Apr 30, 1896 |
| Pierce, John | Murder | Apr 30, 1896 |
| Pointer, John | Murder | Apr 3, 1874 |
| Pointer, John | Murder | Sep 20, 1894 |
| Postoak, John | Murder | Dec 20, 1878 |
| Ross, Kitt | Murder | Aug 6, 1886 |
| Sampson, Samp | Rape | Jul 1, 1896 |
| Sanders, Osey | Murder | Sep 8, 1876 |
| Seeley, Isham | Murder | Apr 21, 1876 |
| Smith, Richard | Murder | Jan 25, 1889 |
| Spaniard, Jack | Murder | Aug 30, 1889 |
| Sprole, Lincoln | Murder | Jul 23, 1886 |
| Stansberry, John | Murder | Jul 9, 1890 |
| Stephens, John | Murder | Jan 14, 1887 |
| Stewart, Henri Dr. | Murder | Aug 29, 1879 |
| Te-O-Lit-Se | Murder | Jun 29, 1883 |
| Thompson, Thomas | Murder | Jul 11, 1884 |
| Thornton, John | Murder | Jun 28, 1892 |
| Tobler, George | Murder | Jan 30, 1890 |
| Valley, John | Murder | Sep 8, 1876 |
| Walker, William | Murder | Jan 25, 1889 |
| Wasson, James | Murder | Apr 23, 1886 |
| Whittington, William | Murder | Sep 3, 1875 |
| Wiley, William Elliott/Colorado Bill | Murder | Aug 29, 1879 |
| Willis, Thomas | Murder | Jan 16, 1890 |
| Wilson, Aaron | Murder | Apr 21, 1876 |
| Wilson, George/James Casherago | Murder | Jul 30, 1896 |
| Wilson, Sinker | Murder | Sep 8, 1876 |
| Wolf, Tunagee | Murder | Oct 10, 1873 |
| Wolf, Young | Murder | Oct 10, 1873 |
| Womankiller, Jack | Murder | Jul 11, 1884 |